YOUNG@HEART ***
*NOTE* I was very tempted to give this film four stars rather than three. I don’t give half stars. If other people do, I have nothing but respect for that. But that’s one of the reasons I have a five star system instead of four. I will only give something four stars if I think that it’s a 10/10 compared with other films in the marketplace. Five stars is perfection – an instant or lasting classic. Young@Heart, after much deliberation, strikes me as a 9/10. So I do hope that clarifies things somewhat.
I don’t see a lot of documentaries. They’re generally much too serious and stark for my individual taste. I like to be either entertained or deeply swept away in my filmgoing experiences. Though I enjoy having my intellect engaged cinematically as much as the next person, I want my emotions to be involved as well. Movies of that particular genre don’t usually motivate me sufficiently to see them. When I do seek one out, it almost inevitably has a musical theme or background.
This motion picture centres on the Northampton, Massachusetts Young@Heart Chorus. It was established in 1982 when all the current members were living in the same housing project. At that point, it was simply a hobby and some excitement for the people involved. They performed locally at a variety of different venues.
Then, one magical evening two years later, Diamond Lil Aubrey launched into an impromptu version of Manfred Mann’s Do Wah Diddy and brought the house down. From then on, it became an EVENT.
The choir has travelled all over the world during the past 20 years. The average age is currently 80, but many of them look much younger. People drop out and return if and when they can. Some have previous musical or theatrical experience. Some don’t. But they all appear to have some measure of talent and their collective enthusiasm makes all the difference. They absolutely love what they’re doing and they’re warmly received wherever they go. Dressed nattily on stage in immaculate white shirts and trendy jeans, they belt out a mixture of alternative rock and classic favourites: I Wanna Be Sedated (The Ramones), I Feel Good (James Brown), Fix You (Coldplay).
The director STEPHEN WALKER documents the final weeks of rehearsal in 2007, when they were about to perform in their home town.
The movie opens with the chorus on stage. There, at the centre of the action, is EILEEN HALL. She’s a delightful Englishwoman with a quick laugh and a sparkling personality. She worked the burlesque circuit when she was younger so she is no stranger to the adulation of an audience. She is singing the great hit by THE CLASH, SHOULD I STAY OR SHOULD I GO – and she’s doing it solo. She’s obviously getting an enormous kick out of it.
She is 92.
JOE BENOIT is one of the most well loved of all the members. He’s quiet but he misses nothing. Joe is in his early 80s. He has a big smile for everyone that he sees and he’s funny in a charming, gentle way. Their choirmaster, Bob Cilman (who’s 54) has assigned Joe to THE TALKING HEADS’ LIFE DURING WARTIME, which will be performed as a duet. Joe has a photographic memory for lyrics. So he’s the man for the job.
FRED KNITTLE returned to the group after his bout with heart disease. He’s all ready outlived the time that his doctor allotted to him and he feels that his health is failing. His rich baritone is not always up to the professional level that he would like. So, in one deeply moving scene at the end of the picture, he writes a letter to the other members. He tells them how grateful he is for their genuine friendship but, due to his health concerns, he won’t be able to participate any longer aside from the odd special request.
This film never panders or condescends to its audience – or to the group itself. Any emotions that it earns are pure and real. People don’t do a lot of thinking about death or mortality before the age of 30. Unless, of course, an individual has a serious brush with it or loved ones have been lost. But, everyone knows (even when they’re young children) that time is precious and has a finite limit.
No one is more aware of these inevitable facts than the people that populate this chorus. During the course of filming, they lose two members permanently within a week of each other. It hits them hard and they are deeply saddened. But they know that their friends would want them to continue entertaining audiences. Regardless of the circumstances, the show must go on.
One of the most stirring centrepieces of the entire film concerns a trip that the choir takes to a local correctional facility. They are going to give an open air concert to the prisoners on site. There is sufficient security in place but, aside from that, nothing separates the audience from the performers. The reaction they get is astonishing.
When they sing Bob Dylan’s Forever Young in tribute to their newly deceased friend, there are tears from many of the hardened souls observing – and they get a rousing standing ovation at the end of the show. At the meet and greet immediately after there were remarks like, “That was the best performance I’ve ever seen.”
There has been a lot said (repeatedly) over the years about the inherent resilience of people in general and the triumph of the human spirit. So much so that it seems a dull cliche. But, every once in a while, there is a beautiful, truthful film that explores these issues with such grace and is so good and genuine that it really transcends all of that.
If you told any of the people in the chorus that they were heroes or inspirational, they’d likely deny it or laugh out loud. I’m sure they don’t think of themselves that way. They’re just out there enjoying the moment and hoping that the people who came to see them feel the same.
But, whether they’re actually aware of it or not, it’s really very profound. By doing this, they’re allowing others to see that that passion, that drive, that sense of adventure never has to be dispensed with or drowned out.
The fact is that people never really change. They just get a little older.
Miss this at your own risk…

April 22, 2008 at 8:18 am
…how many members of the choir said that if they were to die, they wouldn’t want the choir to miss a performance ??? doesn’t matter the exact number that idea was said a few times…..
the coolest twist on that was when a female member said that if she died on stage/they could just drag her body off the stage..and keep singing (words similiar to that).
and if the choir doing a sonic youth song makes some kid feel stupid for used to thinking they were so alternative because they were into nu-metal…
well that would be awesome…..
April 22, 2008 at 2:53 pm
Did you like this movie, glim?
Now that I’ve read your comment I’m not entirely sure…
April 24, 2008 at 5:52 am
m. the movie was ok. or maybe now i’m a bit more used to going to movies, the feeling of not being close to blown away is more acceptable ???
no big hate/disdain from me..but not much enthusiam either.
and yep you/i can call it from the rocks/this will be on gadzillions of people best of year thing….
but forget that miranda..what you really want know of is my encounter with the fox reps after the screening.
well there was this lady that always outside/well at every fox screening i’ve been to asking whatever questions about the movie.
and we met again. i actually think my exact words to her were “we meet again “.
i thought she recognized me. but seems she confused me with some kid at the ’smart people’ screening. note i was not at the ’smart people’ screening. (she remembered me as the kid at that screening that helped her count some stuff. nope not me…)
so it was this lady in late 50’s/early 60’s and two kids early 20’s one male/one female….
anyway seeing how most of the audience at the screening i went to were from a nursing home (ah can i phrase it like that ?? not sure which term i should use ) and the younger types that were there sprinted for the door. yep they didn’t want to wait behind the senior citizens.
i had an excessive (well i’m sure it felt that way to them ) time to talk to fox reps. and boy were their ears tired when i was through….
and it was weird the youngish and uh easy on the eye fox rep was wearing a light blue forgetting sarah marshall tee. so i said what does the shirt say/something similiar….. and she smiled pulled/ tugged so i could make out all the details…. of the shirt….and yeah miranda the shirt was pretty snug..maybe a bit small and her breasts her a bit large for her frame…all from ‘your pals’ at fox….
anyway so i’m babbling about ‘indie’ and fox…..ala…curious what when i signed up for the fox thing they ask for my zip code..but didn’t send me a whatever telling me the free screenings of young@heart in ‘my area’ but i did get an email telling me when it opened in ny/la…makes perfect sense…. (but as i was expecting, this would allow to get to the the theatre at the last second..or as it happened late and still get a seat. yep third row *ouch* )
so youngish college age kid (male) seemed genuinely enthused when babbling about he could see this film playing for six months/word of mouth/expansion etc….
and i mentioned you could tell fox’s ‘expansion’ plan by how many free screenings they did…ala they did 3,000 free screenings for juno…12 or so for the savages….
and i went on about a couple of other things fox/indie related. talking the older female and young college male guy. the easy on the eyes tight forgetting sarah marshall tee female well forget about me. and said nothing.
well wait she never actually said anything to me. but it weird to be systematically ignored (she just sort faced another direction/and folder her arms over her chest) by someone three feet away…especially after she tugs her shirt down for you..
ah but i have that effect….*ha ha *
anyway to keep more off topic going..
fave move so far this year in bruges
best sex scene paranoid park (i’m totally sincere. this scene was disorienting and surprising. and yes i guess it’s just me but i love sex scenes that are either funny/or seem to fun function as an anti(hot) sex scene. and it doesn’t mattewr how badly i attempted to describe this. because no one else ever says anything similiar )
best new movie blog cinematic passions…
April 24, 2008 at 10:50 am
Well, this may be on my Top 10 for the year. I really couldn’t say definitively at this point. As excellent as Y@H was (for me), if this year is anything like 2007, then it hasn’t got a shot in hell…
I LOVE hearing your moviegoing anecdotes, glim. You catch tiny details and other small things that most people would miss. A lot comes into it: peoples’ viewing habits, what they said, what they wore, who they were with (if anyone). It’s like the most fascinating demographics study.
I think you can use the term nursing homes without being politically incorrect at this point. It doesn’t bother me and I don’t think it would even if I were old. But I hear some people call them “retirement communities” now. If that’s progress…
So you think Fox paid this attractive young woman to parade around in a too tight T shirt to promote FSM? God, I thought that those tactics were just about dead. It’s like the old 50s thing where they got models (that didn’t look anything like your average homemaker) to do ads posing with their vacuum cleaners or dust mops. Then in the 60s it was far more suggestive. Babes in bikinis at car shows, on TV scantily clad doing whatever.
Well, I think Fox should have had a great looking guy in a form fitting FSM tee or with tight pants. (They could have emblazoned something directly across his ass.) Two wrongs don’t make a right. ABSOLUTELY. But if they’re going to do one, they might as well do the other.
Personally, I think all of that should be dispensed with entirely. But if you’re going to recruit women for that, us girls want our eye candy too. Fair is fair.
IN BRUGES is my favourite film of the year (so far) as well. I haven’t seen Paranoid Park. I think it’s all ready played here if I’m not mistaken.
“best new movie blog Cinematic Passions”
Thank you, my darling. That’s a wonderful compliment. I think you’re endearingly special too…
April 24, 2008 at 12:10 pm
really m. yep, the female was in the tight sarah marshall tee…the guy was cute and had a pretty good body too. but he wasn’t wearing anything fox related. neither was the older female….
and thanks for your kind words re my unoffical demographic thing. ha ha…
thank you…..
April 25, 2008 at 1:05 am
You’re welcome, sweetie.
Consider CP your home away from home…
April 27, 2008 at 12:18 am
Very, very good review Miranda, even if I have yet to see this film, I cannot wait to. I am becoming a big fan of documentaries done right, and judging from your review, this one seems to have been done near perfectly.
Thanks
April 27, 2008 at 4:35 am
You’re very welcome, my darling – and thank you so much for the compliment.
In my view, Y@H is a wonderful film. Whether it actually ends up in my year end Top 10 doesn’t really matter. This is one of the gems of 2008 and I don’t think anything will ever change that.
I do hope that my recommendation will convince a few people on the fence to take a look at it. I think everyone should see it.
April 27, 2008 at 2:13 pm
I am so over the fence, the side that cannot wait to see it but will no doubt have to wait forever to see it.
April 27, 2008 at 5:13 pm
All good things to those who wait, honey bun.
It’ll be over there before you know it.
May 13, 2008 at 8:11 am
Phenomenal writing, Miranda. I’ve been waiting for weeks to be able to come back to this, which is fact the first review I’ve read of it.
I love the three members that you highlighted here, and wish you could have done so for all of them. One of the greatest strengths of this film is how well we get to know the group members. It’s testament to Stephen Walker’s hands-off approach, and it’s the reason that we’re able to get so many emotions from the music. The lyrics mean a lot more when you know how they apply to someone’s life, not just in Y@H, but in any circumstance.
Love it.
May 13, 2008 at 9:45 am
Thank you so much, Danny. I’m a person who lives for compliments (can’t you tell?) but I’m really getting my quota today – which is wonderful. So I guess that’ll last until…the weekend. Hee hee.
But seriously, I’m so happy you liked the review. In some ways it’s more difficult to write reviews of non fiction films. (You would know MUCH more about this. You see a lot more docs than I do.) You really want to do the people or the issue justice. It seems more important and like there’s a lot more at stake.
Believe me, if I could’ve, I would have written about them all. But we only get to know a certain percentage of the chorus really well. I would’ve needed different press materials and I actually had none. I decided to focus on my favourite people and stick to the basics. You don’t want to go into too much detail because then people will feel like they’ve seen the whole thing. So it was a bit of a challenge to write initially but it was fun to do.
But I have the greatest appreciation for the fact that you liked what I wrote. I’m glad you’re a regular at CP. I’m very happy to have you here…